SnipeWatch

How to Sell Your Trading Cards

SellingReviewed November 4, 20266 minute read

This guide contains affiliate links. How that works.

Sort before you sell

Go through the collection and set aside the cards that are worth selling individually. Most of what is left is bulk, which sells best in lots. Selling every card one at a time is rarely worth the effort and fees.

Where to sell

  • eBay. The largest audience, good for valuable cards and graded cards. Fees apply.
  • TCGplayer. Built for single cards. It handles listings and shipping labels for many games.
  • Your local game store. Fast and simple, but typically pays less than the card’s market value because the shop needs margin.
  • Social groups and meetups. Can work, but the scam risks are higher. See how to avoid collectibles scams.

Price it right

Search for the same card in the same condition and look at what it recently sold for, not what sellers are asking. See how to check card prices. Remember to subtract marketplace fees and shipping.

Photos and descriptions

  • Photograph the front and back of the actual card, in good light, against a plain background.
  • Show any flaws up close. Honest descriptions prevent returns and disputes.
  • State the set, card number, language and condition clearly.

Packing and shipping

  • Put the card in a penny sleeve, then a toploader, and tape the toploader closed.
  • Sandwich it between cardboard in a padded mailer so it cannot bend.
  • Use tracked shipping for anything of value. A plain envelope with no tracking is only for very low-value cards, and you carry the risk if it goes missing.

Keep records

Selling cards can count as taxable income, and the rules depend on where you live. Keep records of what you paid, what you sold for and your fees, and check your local rules or ask an accountant.

Where to look

See what your cards sold for on eBay

Search completed listings to price your cards.

Search on eBay
Toploaders and bubble mailers

Shipping supplies for sold cards.

Search on Amazon
Penny sleeves

Inner protection for shipped cards.

Search on Amazon

Links open a search, so you can compare current listings. Prices and availability change, and we do not control them.

Keep reading